open your purse mickey mouse https://twitter.com/Disney/status/1267224613152571393 …
On social media, companies and influencers who call out police violence are being told to ‘open your purse’
When Missouri teenager Michael Brown was shot by police in 2014, protests erupted across the country, and the #BlackLivesMatter movement was born. When New Yorker Eric Garner was killed by police later that year, a video of him struggling and saying “I can’t breathe” 11 times—before slipping unconscious, and later dying, went viral.
At the time, few corporations spoke out in support of the Black Lives Matter movement or in opposition to police killings of black Americans. But as similar protests took hold of the country again over the past week in response to the police killings of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor and Tony McDade, within days, many of the biggest global U.S.-based brands issued statements in solidarity with the black community.
What changed between 2014 and 2020?
“They’re telling brands, you have to do more, you have to change the situation.”—Lewis Williams, CCO, Burrell Communications
Lewis Williams, CCO and evp at Chicago’s powerhouse multicultural marketing firm Burrell Communications, cited numerous reasons for brands’ sudden willingness to join forces with protesters. Williams said that when it comes to the relationship that younger generations have with brands, “everyone’s expectations have increased. “
“They’re holding brands accountable,” Williams said. “It used to be OK just to say, ‘Oh that’s so bad.’ But now that’s not enough. They’re telling brands, you have to do more, you have to change the situation.”
It’s true that up until now, any brand speaking out against racial injustice was an outlier. When Nike made former San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick the face of its ad campaign in 2018, it was a risky move and one the brand took heat for, due to Kaepernick’s kneeling during the national anthem to raise awareness of police violence against black Americans.
But today, with many companies—and wealthy celebrities—issuing blunt statements against racism on social media, many equality advocates online are responding with three simple words: “open your purse.”
The edict of “open your purse” in the face of empty platitudes from celebrities, multi-million pound media platforms and corporations is really something to witness. People refusing symbolism and demanding wealth redistribution and material action.
Some major brands have already stepped up to the plate, backing up their statements of support with actionable plans for contributing to the black community’s fight for justice.
On Friday, YouTube pledged to donate $1 million “in support of efforts to address social injustice.”
And on Sunday, luxury makeup brand Glossier announced it would split $1 million between two efforts: $500,000 going to racial justice groups like Black Lives Matter, and another $500,000 going into grants for black-owned beauty businesses.
Brands have to offer something measurable, said Williams, because today’s consumers expect more than just words—especially after the way brands responded to the Covid-19 pandemic by throwing millions of dollars in donations at various communities.
Williams said the criticism and anger aimed at brands and influencers that do little beyond offering words of support stem not just from rage and grief over the crisis of police brutality, but also from the powder keg created by unprecedented mass unemployment and pandemic stress.
“‘Coronavirus is killing me, I don’t know if I have work, and it just erupted,’” said Williams, emulating how many consumers feel. “And there’s no leadership in this country right now, and people are really looking for a leader…so we’re looking at brands. Who can I turn to for help?”
But as people turn to brands for leadership, they aren’t satisfied with reassuring tweets alone. When Amazon posted a statement on its social media channels saying it “stand[s] in solidarity with the black community,” former employee Chris Smalls—famously fired after helping organize a picket over unsafe pandemic working conditions—pointed out the irony.
“It’s extremely insulting on the day where they took away the $2 ‘hero pay,’ which affects the black and brown employees directly who make up a majority of their workforce,” Smalls told Adweek on Sunday. “It’s disgraceful for them to even say such a thing when they oppress their own workers of color. Everyone that was fired over the last two months was black or brown or women with the exception of Emily Cunningham and Maren Costa, who were fired because they stood with us in solidarity.”
After Smalls was fired, a leaked document revealed that Amazon’s general counsel had brushed Smalls off as “not smart or articulate.” The activist is still participating in organizing work to raise awareness around working conditions for Amazon’s low-wage workers, as well as attending this week’s protests in Newark.
“Ask Amazon the percent ratio of how many black people hold vice president or regional positions in that company,” said Smalls, saying the company needed to take internal action before it can claim to support the black community.
For some black-led businesses, the approach is more intimate and more robust. On Sunday, BET announced that it was partnering with leading civil rights organizations like NAACP and Color of Change on “immediate calls to action,” as well as planning to run a public service announcement in partnership with Black Lives Matter.
“Our community’s grief is not new; it is simply being filmed,” read a statement from BET staff. “Images of Black bodies hanging from trees or hunted down in the street are interwoven into this nation’s very roots, inextricably enmeshed in Americana. These violent acts of hatred are the result of long-standing and systematic racism. There is no quick solution to the complex problems we face, however, BET is working with a broad coalition to activate against these challenges and affect change. This duty belongs to all of us, and we owe it to our country.”
Williams said he hopes that brands will engage in efforts that go beyond donating funds to activist groups.
“Money is not enough. We have to change. It has to be something measurable,” said Williams. “The easiest thing [for a brand] to do is to give someone $2 million and walk away. If the money isn’t going where it’s supposed to, it’s not doing anything.”